In a report published this week, the European Union delegation to South Africa said that for more than a year poultry imported into South Africa from the EU had been singled out and subjected to aggressive and hostile attacks by local poultry industry lobbyists.
The South African authorities have banned much of the poultry exports from the EU in an unprecedented protectionist drive.
The 2 page EU document alleges that false allegations have been made in “official proceedings” and carried in the media that the poultry imports from the EU undermine local poultry producers due to:
- Enormous quantity of bone-in chicken parts
- Chicken parts of inferior quality to those consumed in the EU (“trash”)
- Chicken sold at prices that local producers cannot match (“dumping”)
- Chicken produce that benefits from subsidies
- …with the alleged result of job losses in South Africa
EU: Facts do not bear out allegations
But the EU says the facts do not bear out the allegations, stressing the quantity of poultry imported to South Africa from the EU has drastically decreased since December 2016 and has been replaced by imports from third country producers, such as the United States and Brazil but not by domestic production. Imports from non-EU counties in 2017 stood at 175,950 tonnes, having almost quadrupled from the 45,200 tonnes imported into South Africa in 2016
EU imports to SA not recovered since AI outbreak
Prior to December 2016, EU producers were able to meet South African demand for frozen bone-in chicken parts, known as “safeguard cuts”. But following an outbreak of highly pathogenic avian influenza across much of Europe, EU chicken exports plummeted in 2017 and have shown no signs of recovery this year.
The EU says imports of “safeguard” cuts from the EU were down 71.9% in 2017 compared to the previous year.
In response to the other issues raised, it says:
- EU poultry imports to South Africa are of the same quality as that sold in the EU. EU food law and regulations impose high standards on food safety. Unlike in South Africa , there is no brining in the EU – if a poultry product is brined, it cannot be sold or exported as fresh/frozen chicken meat
- The EU does not subsidise poultry production or exports
- EU broiler prices are consistently above those of other big importers in South Africa, such as Brazil and the United States. If there was any dumping taking place, the EU would expect the South African Poultry Association to file a dumping complaint to SA’s International Trade Administration Commission.